Removing unecessary plans

This commit is contained in:
michael committed 2026-07-02 18:11:43 -07:00
1 parent b30bde22f6
commit f4214a0a83
2 files changed
-220

No files matched your search

@@ -1,86 +0,0 @@
# hf mfu esetblk — Design Document
**Date:** 2026-07-02
**Branch:** hf-mfu-esetblk
**Goal:** Add `hf mfu esetblk`, mirroring `hf mf esetblk` but for Ultralight/NTAG (MFU) 4-byte page memory, so users can set emulator-memory page(s) directly (for building/patching an emulated UL/NTAG tag without re-running a full `eload`).
---
## Background
`hf mf esetblk` ([cmdhfmf.c:5216](../../client/src/cmdhfmf.c#L5216), `CmdHF14AMfESet`) sets exactly one 16-byte MIFARE Classic block in emulator memory: it requires precisely 16 hex bytes and calls `mf_elm_set_mem(data, blk, 1)`.
MFU/NTAG emulator memory is different: 4-byte **pages**, stored in BigBuf as an `mfu_dump_t` — a **56-byte prefix** (version[8], tbo, pages, signature[32], counter_tearing[12]) followed by page data. The firmware sim serves GET_VERSION/READ_SIG from that prefix and READ(0x30)/FAST_READ(0x3A) from the page data at BigBuf offset `page*4 + 56`.
No `hf mfu esetblk` exists yet — the MFU emulator family is only `eload` / `esave` / `eview` ([cmdhfmfu.c:8082-8084](../../client/src/cmdhfmfu.c#L8082-L8084)).
The write path is **already width-parameterized**: `mf_eml_set_mem_xt(data, blockNum, count, width)` ([mifarehost.c:1098](../../client/src/mifare/mifarehost.c#L1098)) → `CMD_HF_MIFARE_EML_MEMSET` → device `emlSetMem_xt` (offset = `blockNum * width`). MFU `eload` already calls it with `width = MFU_BLOCK_SIZE (4)`. **So this is a client-only command — no firmware change, no new helper.**
---
## Command
`hf mfu esetblk` — handler `CmdHF14AMfUeSetBlk` in `cmdhfmfu.c`, registered in the MFU command table next to `eload`/`esave`/`eview`:
```c
{"esetblk", CmdHF14AMfUeSetBlk, IfPm3Iso14443a, "Set emulator memory block"},
```
**Args** (mirror `esetblk`):
- `-b` / `--blk <dec>` — start page (required)
- `-d` / `--data <hex>` — page bytes; length a nonzero multiple of 4 (one page = 4 bytes)
**Frictionless multi-page:** the page count is inferred from the data length — no extra flag. One page (`-d <8 hex>`) is the common case (`count = 1`); longer data writes consecutive pages from `--blk`.
---
## Semantics / internals
Write `count = datalen / MFU_BLOCK_SIZE` pages starting at card page `blk`:
```c
mf_eml_set_mem_xt(data, blk + (MFU_DUMP_PREFIX_LENGTH / MFU_BLOCK_SIZE), count, MFU_BLOCK_SIZE);
// page blk + 14 (skip the 56-byte mfu_dump_t prefix) width 4
```
The `+14` targets page data past the prefix, exactly as the firmware's own WRITE(0xA2) handler does (`emlSetMem_xt(..., block + MFU_DUMP_PREFIX_LENGTH/4, 1, 4)`).
Then: `PrintAndLogEx(SUCCESS, "Set %u page(s) from page %u", count, blk)`.
---
## Validation
- `datalen == 0 || datalen % MFU_BLOCK_SIZE != 0` → `"data must be whole pages (multiples of 4 bytes)"`, `PM3_EINVARG`.
- **Max page 254** (not 255): the live MFU emulator data region is `MFU_MAX_BYTES = MFU_MAX_BLOCKS(0xFF) * MFU_BLOCK_SIZE = 1020` bytes = 255 pages, indices **0–254**. Page 255 (`data[1020..1024]`) is beyond what `esave`/`eview` transfer, so cap so everything set is round-trippable:
```c
if ((blk + count) * MFU_BLOCK_SIZE > MFU_MAX_BYTES) { // last page must be <= 254
PrintAndLogEx(WARNING, "page range exceeds emulator memory (max page %u)",
(MFU_MAX_BYTES / MFU_BLOCK_SIZE) - 1);
return PM3_EINVARG;
}
```
- Parse `-d` into a buffer sized `MFU_MAX_BYTES` (1020).
> Note on the constants: `MFU_MAX_BLOCKS = 0xFF` is a page **count**, not a max index; `eview`/`esave` validate `end > MFU_MAX_BLOCKS`, which loosely admits `--end 255` even though only pages 0–254 are live. `esetblk` uses the tighter, correct `MFU_MAX_BYTES` bound.
---
## Reuse (no duplication)
- `mf_eml_set_mem_xt` — existing width-parameterized emulator-write helper.
- `CMD_HF_MIFARE_EML_MEMSET` / `emlSetMem_xt` — existing device path, unchanged.
- Model the handler on `CmdHF14AMfESet` ([cmdhfmf.c:5216](../../client/src/cmdhfmf.c#L5216)); the deltas are width 4, the `+14` prefix offset, multi-page count, and the max-254 bound.
---
## Testing
Emulator-memory commands need a connected PM3 but **no card**, and have no offline unit path, so verification is a hardware smoke test:
1. `hf mfu esetblk -b 4 -d 04E10CDA` → `hf mfu eview`, confirm page 4 = `04 E1 0C DA`.
2. Multi-page: `hf mfu esetblk -b 4 -d 04E10CDA993C8048` → `eview`, confirm pages 4-5.
3. Error cases rejected cleanly: odd length (`-d 04E10C`), and out-of-range (`-b 254 -d <16+ bytes>` → would touch page 255).
---
## Out of scope (YAGNI)
- Setting `mfu_dump_t` prefix fields (version/signature/counters) — use `eload` of a full dump.
- `eget` / `eclr` for MFU.
-134
View File
@@ -1,134 +0,0 @@
# hf mfu esetblk Implementation Plan
> **For Claude:** REQUIRED SUB-SKILL: Use superpowers:executing-plans to implement this plan task-by-task.
**Goal:** Add a client-only `hf mfu esetblk` command that writes one or more 4-byte pages into MFU/NTAG emulator memory, mirroring `hf mf esetblk` but for Ultralight page structures.
**Architecture:** A single new handler `CmdHF14AMfUeSetBlk` in `client/src/cmdhfmfu.c` that parses `--blk`/`--data`, validates whole-page data and the max-254 page bound, and calls the existing width-parameterized helper `mf_eml_set_mem_xt(...)` with `width=4` and a `+14` page offset (to skip the 56-byte `mfu_dump_t` prefix). Registered in the MFU command table. No firmware change, no new helpers.
**Tech Stack:** C (proxmark3 client), CLIParser arg tables, `mf_eml_set_mem_xt` → `CMD_HF_MIFARE_EML_MEMSET`. Build: `make client`. Design: `docs/plans/2026-07-02-hf-mfu-esetblk-design.md`.
**Note on testing:** MFU emulator commands are `IfPm3Iso14443a` (device required) and have **no offline unit-test path**. So this plan is not TDD — verification is: clean build, `-h` help renders offline, and an on-device smoke test (PM3 needed, **no card**). The logic is a close structural copy of the already-working `hf mf esetblk`.
---
## Task 1: Implement and register `hf mfu esetblk`
**Files:**
- Modify: `client/src/cmdhfmfu.c` — add handler `CmdHF14AMfUeSetBlk` (near the other `CmdHF14AMfUe*` handlers) + one command-table row.
- Reference (read, do not modify): `client/src/cmdhfmf.c:5216` (`CmdHF14AMfESet`, the template); `client/src/mifare/mifarehost.c:1098` (`mf_eml_set_mem_xt` signature).
**Step 1: Confirm the helper is declared for this translation unit.**
Run: `grep -nE 'mf_eml_set_mem_xt' /home/work/proxmark3/.worktrees/hf-mfu-esetblk/client/src/mifare/mifarehost.h`
Expected: a prototype line. If cmdhfmfu.c does not already include `mifare/mifarehost.h`, add `#include "mifare/mifarehost.h"` with the other includes. (Confirm it compiles in Step 4.)
Signature to use:
```c
int mf_eml_set_mem_xt(uint8_t *data, int blockNum, int blocksCount, int blockBtWidth);
```
**Step 2: Add the handler** in `client/src/cmdhfmfu.c` (place it just above the `CommandTable[]` array, next to `CmdHF14AMfuEView` / `CmdHF14AMfUeLoad`):
```c
static int CmdHF14AMfUeSetBlk(const char *Cmd) {
CLIParserContext *ctx;
CLIParserInit(&ctx, "hf mfu esetblk",
"Set emulator memory page(s). One page = 4 bytes; pass multiple\n"
"whole pages of data to set consecutive pages from --blk.",
"hf mfu esetblk --blk 4 -d 04E10CDA\n"
"hf mfu esetblk --blk 4 -d 04E10CDA993C8048 -> sets pages 4-5\n"
);
void *argtable[] = {
arg_param_begin,
arg_int1("b", "blk", "<dec>", "page number to start at"),
arg_str0("d", "data", "<hex>", "bytes to write, whole pages (multiple of 4 bytes)"),
arg_param_end
};
CLIExecWithReturn(ctx, Cmd, argtable, false);
int blk = arg_get_int_def(ctx, 1, 0);
uint8_t data[MFU_MAX_BYTES] = {0x00};
int datalen = 0;
int res = CLIParamHexToBuf(arg_get_str(ctx, 2), data, sizeof(data), &datalen);
CLIParserFree(ctx);
if (res) {
PrintAndLogEx(FAILED, "Error parsing bytes");
return PM3_EINVARG;
}
if (blk < 0) {
PrintAndLogEx(WARNING, "page number must be positive");
return PM3_EINVARG;
}
if (datalen == 0 || (datalen % MFU_BLOCK_SIZE) != 0) {
PrintAndLogEx(WARNING, "data must be whole pages (multiples of %d bytes). Got %i", MFU_BLOCK_SIZE, datalen);
return PM3_EINVARG;
}
int count = datalen / MFU_BLOCK_SIZE;
// live MFU emulator data region is MFU_MAX_BYTES (pages 0..254); page 255 is not round-trippable
if ((blk + count) * MFU_BLOCK_SIZE > MFU_MAX_BYTES) {
PrintAndLogEx(WARNING, "page range exceeds emulator memory (max page %u)", (MFU_MAX_BYTES / MFU_BLOCK_SIZE) - 1);
return PM3_EINVARG;
}
// MFU emulator page data starts after the 56-byte mfu_dump_t prefix, so shift the
// page index by MFU_DUMP_PREFIX_LENGTH/MFU_BLOCK_SIZE (=14), width = MFU_BLOCK_SIZE (4).
res = mf_eml_set_mem_xt(data, blk + (MFU_DUMP_PREFIX_LENGTH / MFU_BLOCK_SIZE), count, MFU_BLOCK_SIZE);
if (res != PM3_SUCCESS) {
PrintAndLogEx(FAILED, "Failed to set emulator memory");
return res;
}
PrintAndLogEx(SUCCESS, "Set " _YELLOW_("%d") " page(s) from page " _YELLOW_("%d"), count, blk);
return PM3_SUCCESS;
}
```
**Step 3: Register the command** in the MFU `CommandTable[]` (near `eload`/`esave`/`eview`, ~cmdhfmfu.c:8082-8084):
```c
{"esetblk", CmdHF14AMfUeSetBlk, IfPm3Iso14443a, "Set emulator memory block"},
```
**Step 4: Build.**
Run: `cd /home/work/proxmark3/.worktrees/hf-mfu-esetblk && make client -j"$(nproc)"`
Expected: clean build, no warnings on cmdhfmfu.c, `client/proxmark3` linked.
**Step 5: Verify help renders (offline).**
Run: `QT_QPA_PLATFORM=offscreen ./pm3 -o -c 'hf mfu esetblk -h'`
Expected: usage text with `--blk` and `--data`, no crash.
Also confirm it now appears in the menu: `QT_QPA_PLATFORM=offscreen ./pm3 -o -c 'hf mfu help'` lists `esetblk`.
**Step 6: Commit.**
```bash
cd /home/work/proxmark3/.worktrees/hf-mfu-esetblk
git add client/src/cmdhfmfu.c
git commit -m "feat(mfu): add hf mfu esetblk to set emulator memory pages"
```
---
## Task 2: On-device smoke test (requires a PM3, no card)
Not automatable here — hand these to the user. Record results in the commit/PR notes.
1. **Single page:** `hf mfu esetblk -b 4 -d 04E10CDA` → then `hf mfu eview` → page 4 shows `04 E1 0C DA`.
2. **Multi-page:** `hf mfu esetblk -b 4 -d 04E10CDA993C8048` → `eview` → pages 4 and 5 both set.
3. **Odd length rejected:** `hf mfu esetblk -b 4 -d 04E10C` → `"data must be whole pages…"`, no write.
4. **Out of range rejected:** `hf mfu esetblk -b 254 -d 0011223344556677` (2 pages → would touch page 255) → `"page range exceeds emulator memory (max page 254)"`.
5. **Round-trip:** `esetblk` a few pages → `hf mfu esave -f /tmp/t` → reload/compare, confirm the set pages persisted.
---
## YAGNI / out of scope
- Setting `mfu_dump_t` prefix fields (version/signature/counters) — use `eload`.
- `eget`/`eclr` for MFU.
- Any firmware change (none needed).